Bay Shore Insurance Agency · Bay Shore, NY

Old-school service, modern protection.

Bay Shore’s hometown insurance agency since 1978 — auto, home, boat, and business coverage from people who actually answer the phone.

Serving Bay Shore Since 1978Licensed NY Agency24/7 Claims Help
45+ years

Three generations of Bay Shore families.

20+ carriers

Independent — we shop for you.

Scroll

Welcome

Bay Shore’s trusted insurance agency.

J.D.A. Hurley has sat on East Main Street since 1978 — back when quotes came by phone and handshakes closed deals. The tools changed; the promise didn’t.

Our story →

Inside J.D.A. Hurley

What we do

Everything you need, under one roof.

J.D.A. Hurley has served Bay Shore and surrounding Long Island towns for years with honest work and clear pricing.

01

Auto Insurance

From first cars to family fleets — coverage that fits the way you drive.

  • Liability & collision
  • Teen driver policies
  • Multi-car discounts

02

Homeowners Insurance

South Shore homes face real weather. We make sure you’re ready for it.

  • Dwelling coverage
  • Hurricane deductibles
  • Flood options

03

Boat & Marine

The Great South Bay is our backyard — we insure what floats on it.

  • Boat & yacht
  • Personal watercraft
  • Marina liability

04

Life Insurance

Straightforward term and permanent options to protect the people you love.

  • Term life
  • Whole life
  • Free needs review

05

Business Insurance

Main Street shops, contractors, and marine trades — covered right.

  • General liability
  • Workers’ comp
  • Commercial property

06

Umbrella Coverage

Extra liability protection above your auto and home policies.

  • $1M+ limits
  • Affordable premiums
  • One-policy simplicity
0Years in Bay Shore*
0Policies written*
0Carrier options*
0Client retention*

* Illustrative figures for this concept demo — ask us for the real numbers when we talk.

The difference

See what Hurley can do.

Exposed
Covered
↔
Exposed Covered

Forty-five years of showing up.

How it works

Simple from first call to finish.

Call or stop in

Main Street office, real humans, no phone trees.

We shop 20+ carriers

Independent means options, not one company’s pitch.

Choose your coverage

Plain-English options at honest prices.

We’re here at claim time

One call, any hour — we stay on it with you.

Kind words

Neighbors who trust us.

★★★★★
“My family’s been with Hurley for thirty years. Three generations, zero regrets.”
— Homeowner, Bay Shore
★★★★★
“They handled my boat, my truck, and my house — one call does it all.”
— Boater, Islip
★★★★★
“After the storm, they had an adjuster out in two days. That’s why you go local.”
— Homeowner, Brightwaters

Testimonials are illustrative examples for this concept demo.

Questions

Asked all the time.

Yes — boat, yacht, and personal watercraft policies are a specialty here on the South Shore, including marina liability.

Because when something happens, you call someone who knows your name — not a chatbot. We also re-shop your policies every year.

Yes, and bundling usually saves 10–25%. One agency, one call, one renewal date to remember.

Absolutely — many Bay Shore homes need it, and standard homeowners policies exclude flood. We’ll tell you straight whether you do.

Call us any time — we provide 24/7 claims help and stay involved until your claim is resolved.

Yes — all of the Town of Islip and Suffolk County, including Islip, Brightwaters, West Islip, and Brentwood.

Service area

Proudly serving Bay Shore & beyond.

Ready when you are.

One call is all it takes. Talk to a real person at J.D.A. Hurley today — free consultation, zero pressure.

☎ Call (631) 665-6060